Gary Lineker Controversy: BBC takes presenter off

The balance between impartiality and freedom of expression at the BBC

BBC sorry as programmes dropped in Lineker row
BBC sorry as programmes dropped in Lineker row

The BBC has found itself embroiled in a growing controversy following its decision to remove Gary Lineker as host of Match of the Day. As a result, a number of BBC football shows, both on TV and radio, were taken off air after presenters withdrew in “solidarity” with Lineker.

BBC One’s Final Score and Football Focus, hosted by Jason Mohammad and Alex Scott respectively, were among the shows pulled from broadcast on Saturday. Similarly, BBC 5 Live’s Fighting Talk did not air on Saturday morning, with host Colin Murray citing “obvious reasons” for its cancellation.

The controversy has also led to radio host Mark Chapman withdrawing from hosting BBC Radio 5 Live Sport. The decision to remove Lineker from Match of the Day has been criticized by many, leading to a backlash that has spread across various BBC sports shows. This has resulted in a situation where there were no hosts, pundits, or regular commentators on Saturday’s edition of Match of the Day.

The BBC’s move has been perceived by some as an attempt to ensure impartiality in sports coverage. However, others have argued that it is unfair to punish Lineker for expressing his personal opinions outside of his role as a BBC presenter. The situation remains ongoing, with many calling for a resolution that balances the need for impartiality with the right of presenters to express their views.

Gary Lineker, a presenter for the BBC’s Match of the Day, will not be appearing on the show until an agreement is reached regarding his social media use. The decision follows a controversy over Lineker’s impartiality after he compared the language used to launch a new government asylum policy with 1930s Germany on Twitter.

The BBC said in a statement that Lineker’s recent social media activity breached their guidelines and that he should keep away from taking sides on political issues. However, Lineker had earlier stated that he would still be presenting the show as usual. In response, the Professional Footballers Association announced that players involved in Saturday’s matches would not be participating in interviews with Match of the Day. The BBC’s decision has drawn criticism from Labour and support from Conservative politicians, while Lineker has received support from some media figures.

The future of Gary Lineker’s role as host of the BBC’s Match of the Day is under question, as he stands by his principles and refuses to apologise for his political views. Other regular faces on the show, including Ian Wright, Alan Shearer, Alex Scott, Micah Richards, and Jermaine Jenas, have also announced they will not be taking part in the upcoming episode.

Lineker signed a five-year deal with the BBC in 2020, agreeing to adhere to their impartiality rules. While those working in news and current affairs must be completely impartial, those in the sports department, like Lineker, have a bit more freedom. However, they still have a responsibility to avoid bringing the BBC into disrepute and not take sides on political issues or controversies.

Many have come to Lineker’s defense, pointing out the political affiliations of other high-profile figures at the BBC, including chairman Richard Sharp, who has donated £400,000 to the Conservative Party, and board member Sir Robbie Gibb, who previously served as communications director for former Prime Minister Theresa May.

Critics question why Lineker is being singled out, particularly when there are more pressing political issues to be discussed, such as the government’s proposed new asylum policy, which has been condemned by human rights groups and the United Nations. While Lineker has been allowed to criticize Qatar’s human rights record on the BBC, he is not allowed to comment on the human rights record of the country he lives in, leading some to call for a reevaluation of the BBC’s impartiality guidelines.

Leave a Reply